P. Massin et al., CEMENTED ACETABULAR REVISION OF ASEPTIC C EMENTED HIP ARTHROPLASTIES LOOSENING USING A SUPERIOR STRUCTURAL BONE-GRAFT AND A MULLER RING, Revue de chirurgie orthopedique et reparatrice de l'appareil moteur, 84(1), 1998, pp. 51-60
Introduction One reason for the limited longevity of total hip replace
ment is the progressive bone loss resulting from iterative loosenings
of acetabular components. In the early 80's was developed an experienc
e at our institution for revision surgery of aseptically failed cement
ed acetabular components using a Muller ring. At that time, this devic
e was used in combination with structural grafts. This appeared to us
to be the safest method to adress severe acetabular destructions. We a
re now able to report long term results. Material and methods We carri
ed out a retrospective study on 81 cemented acetabular revision arthro
plasties performed at our institution between 1981 and 1991. In all ca
ses, there was a segmental or an important cavitary roof defect. Recon
struction of the acetabulum was performed using a superior structural
bone graft combined with a Muller ring. Results are given with a mean
follow up of 8 years (5-14 years), except in the survivor analysis, in
which all patients were included. Results There was 15 iterative asep
tic loosenings of the acetabular component (in which 5 repeated revisi
ons). Using iterative aseptic loosening of the acetabular component re
vised or not as an end point, the 10 year cumulative survival rate (CS
R) was 0,72 +/- 0,14 and the 11 year CSR was 0,55 +/- 0,24. The positi
on of the hip biomechanical center, the polyethylene thickness, or the
type of the superior defect (segmental or cavitary) were not found to
influence significantly roentgenographic results. Discussion Reconstr
uction of severely destroyed acetabuli using this method gave satisfac
tory results within the first decade. However, the hip function could
not be reliably maintained over 10 years. Mechanical failures were rel
ated to resorption of weight bearing structural bone grafts. Aseptic i
terative loosenings are often moderately symptomatic and yearly roentg
enographic controls are necessary to detect late migrations. The lack
of long term follow up may result in major bone loss, which can impair
the conditions of iterative acetabular reconstructions.