Extra-pair matings are now recognized as a fundamental component of av
ian mating systems. However, in tropical regions where breeding is typ
ically asynchronous socially monogamous species appear to have low spe
rm competition and few extrapair matings. We predicted that if breedin
g synchrony promotes the evolution of extra-pair matings, then tropica
l species that breed synchronously, like the Clay-colored Robin Turdus
grayi, should have abundant extra-pair young (EPY). Breeding began re
latively abruptly during the dry season (Feb-Mar) in this non-migrator
y species, with a mean of 25% of females fertile on a given day. Overa
ll, 53% of females produced EPY, and 38% of nestlings were EPY. Males
have a long and conspicuous dawn chorus, which could be a result of in
tense male-male competition for extra-pair matings. Male songs are ind
ividually recognizable and males vary greatly in song output. Male son
g output declined significantly from the pre-nesting stage through the
incubation stage, as would be expected if song is important in mate c
hoice. Our results support the idea that breeding synchrony favors ext
ra-pair matings, however further studies of tropical songbirds are nee
ded to fully explore how ecology is tied to extra-pair mating systems.