J. Oosterlaan et al., RESPONSE-INHIBITION IN AD HD, CD, COMORBID AD/HD+CD, ANXIOUS, AND CONTROL CHILDREN - A METAANALYSIS OF STUDIES WITH THE STOP TASK/, Journal of child psychology and psychiatry and allied disciplines, 39(3), 1998, pp. 411-425
The aim of this study was to investigate whether impaired response inh
ibition is uniquely related to AD/HD or whether deficits in response i
nhibition are also evident in other psychopathological disorders. Furt
hermore, the suggestion was examined that anxiety disorders are associ
ated with abnormally high levels of response inhibition. This paper pr
esents the results of a meta-analysis of eight studies in which respon
se inhibition was assessed with the so-called stop task in five groups
of children: children with attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder (
AD/HD), children with conduct disorder (CD), children with AD/HD + CD,
children with anxiety disorders, and control children. A total of 456
children participated in the 8 studies. All children were in the age
range 6-12 years. Consistent and robust evidence was found for a respo
nse inhibition deficit in AD/HD. However, response inhibition deficits
did not distinguish children with AD/HD from children with CD, nor fr
om children with comorbid AD/HD + CD. Contrary to predictions, anxious
children did not demonstrate enhanced levels of response inhibition.