THE EFFECT OF A KNOWLEDGE-BASED, IMAGE-ANALYSIS AND CLINICAL DECISION-SUPPORT SYSTEM ON OBSERVER PERFORMANCE IN THE DIAGNOSIS OF APPROXIMALCARIES FROM RADIOGRAPHIC IMAGES
Ar. Firestone et al., THE EFFECT OF A KNOWLEDGE-BASED, IMAGE-ANALYSIS AND CLINICAL DECISION-SUPPORT SYSTEM ON OBSERVER PERFORMANCE IN THE DIAGNOSIS OF APPROXIMALCARIES FROM RADIOGRAPHIC IMAGES, Caries research, 32(2), 1998, pp. 127-134
The aim of this study was to investigate the effect of a knowledge-bas
ed image analysis and clinical decision support system (CariesFinder(C
), CF) on diagnostic performance and therapeutic decisions. The study
material consisted of radiographic images of 102 approximal surfaces,
35 sound, 67 caries (25 caries and cavitated and 42 caries). Sixteen g
eneral practitioners were presented with (1) radiographic film images
and (2) digital filmless images with the results of CE The viewers wer
e asked to respond whether approximal caries was present and whether a
restoration was indicated. Responses were analyzed for accuracy, sens
itivity, specificity and agreement. Further, the practitioners were ra
nked according to the accuracy of their restorative decisions and assi
gned to ten overlapping groups of 7 practitioners. For each group the
diagnostic and therapeutic decisions were then examined for unanimity
The parameters of accuracy, sensitivity and specificity were then esta
blished for each group based on only unanimous, correct decisions. The
diagnostic and therapeutic accuracy of CF alone was equal or superior
to the decisions of the practitioners viewing film images alone. For
unanimous decisions, CF alone was more accurate than the most accurate
group of practitioners and made fewer incorrect decisions to restore
non-cavitated surfaces than the practitioners. In general, dental prac
titioners viewing the results of CF significantly increased their abil
ity to diagnose caries correctly their overall diagnostic accuracy, an
d their ability to recommend restorations for cavitated surfaces. Ther
e was a decrease in the accuracy of their restorative decisions overal
l and in the specificity in particular.