We showed that the efficacy of the new 2'-deoxycytidine (2'-dCyd) anal
ogue antimetabolite 2'-deoxy-2'-methylidenecytidine (DMDC) correlates
well with tumor levels of cytidine (Cyd) deaminase in human cancer xen
ograft models. DMDC was highly effective in tumors with higher levels
of Cyd deaminase, whereas lower levels yielded only slight activity. I
n contrast, gemcitabine (2',2'-difluorodeoxycytidine), which has actio
n mechanisms similar to those of DMDC, is only slightly active in tumo
rs with higher levels of the enzyme. In the present study, we investig
ated the roles of Cyd deaminase in the antitumor activity of the two 2
'-dCyd antimetabolites in 13 human cancer cell lines, Tetrahydrouridin
e, an inhibitor of Cyd deaminase, reduced the antiproliferative activi
ty of DMDC (P = 0.0015). Furthermore, tumor cells transfected with the
gene of human Cyd deaminase become more susceptible to DMDC both in v
itro and in vivo. These results indicate that Cyd deaminase is indeed
essential for the activity of DMDC. In contrast, the antiproliferative
activity of gemcitabine was increased to some extent by tetrahydrouri
dine (P = 0.0277), particularly in tumor cell Lines with higher levels
of Cyd deaminase. This suggests that higher levels of Cyd deaminase m
ay inactivate gemcitabine. Among nucleosides and deoxynucleosides test
ed, only dCyd, a natural substrate of both Cyd deaminase and dCyd kina
se, suppressed the antiproliferative activity of DMDC by up to 150-fol
d. Because the V-max/K-m of DMDC for dCyd kinase was I-fold lower than
that for dCyd, the activation of DMDC to DMDC monophosphate (DMDCMP)
by dCyd kinase might be competitively inhibited by dCyd. In addition,
the dCyd concentrations in human cancer xenografts were inversely corr
elated with levels of Cyd deaminase activity. It is therefore suggeste
d that higher levels of Cyd deaminase reduce the intrinsic cellular co
ncentrations of dCyd in tumors, resulting in efficient activation of D
MDC to DMDCMP by dCyd kinase. These results indicate that the efficacy
of DMDC may be predicted by measuring the activity of Cyd deaminase i
n tumor tissues before treatment starts and that DMDC may be exploited
in a new treatment modality: tumor enzyme-driven cancer chemotherapy.