In this essay, I suggest that the crisis in our understanding of ferti
lity transitions is more apparent than real. Although most existing th
eories of fertility transition have been partially or wholly discredit
ed, this reflects a tendency to assume that all fertility transitions
share one or two causes, to ignore mortality decline as a precondition
for fertility decline, to assume that pretransitional fertility is wh
olly governed by social constraints rather than by individual decision
-making, and to test ideas on a decadal time scale. I end the essay by
suggesting a perceptual, interactive approach to explaining fertility
transitions that is closely allied to existing theories but focuses o
n conditions that lead couples to switch from postnatal to prenatal co
ntrols on family size.