Recently, the role of task analysis in design has been brought into qu
estion. It has been argued, for example, that task analysis leads to t
he non-creative redesign of existing artefacts. In this paper, we offe
r a view of task analysis that resolves this problem. In particular, w
e argue that by focusing upon the analysis of user/operator goals rath
er than an existing task implementation, task analysis encourages nove
l and apt design. A reformulation of hierarchical task analysis is off
ered, based on the sub-goal template (SGT) scheme. The SGT scheme prov
ides a notation for goal-oriented task analysis and defines an appropr
iate level at which task analyses can inform the design process withou
t constraining it to existing task implementations. The SGT scheme is
compared with the systems analysis-based design methodology SSADM and
the advantages of each approach are reviewed. (C) 1998 Elsevier Scienc
e B.V.