Previous work has established that women with good marriages are less
at risk of depression of clinical severity following a crisis than wom
en in poor quality relationships. Evidence for such protectiveness is
less clear for men. The paper examines the relationship between marita
l quality, onset of depression, and gender following a severely threat
ening life event. The results show that good quality of marriage relat
ed to lower rates of depression for both men and women, although the o
verall rate for women was higher. For women with a good marital relati
onship, but for whom support from partner was not forthcoming at the t
ime of the crisis (i.e. the person was ''let down''), risk was increas
ed, confirming a result from a study in Islington. The current study s
hows that the same set of findings holds for men. Gender differences d
id emerge when the subjective need for support within the marital rela
tionship is taken into account, with women expressing greater need. Ho
wever, such a desire for support was not necessarily translated into s
upport-seeking behaviour as in a poor relationship turning to a partne
r was frequently inopportune. Women were also more likely to seek supp
ort outside the marriage; as in the earlier Islington research this wa
s related to a lower risk of depression for those in a poor relationsh
ip. An unexpected finding was that men who received support outside ma
rriage had an increased risk of depression. (C) 1998 Elsevier Science
Ltd. All rights reserved.