R. Schnepf et al., RESONANCE RAMAN-SPECTROSCOPIC STUDY OF PHENOXYL RADICAL COMPLEXES, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 120(10), 1998, pp. 2352-2364
Resonance Raman (RR) spectroscopy has been employed to study coordinat
ed phenoxyl radicals (M = Ga, Sc, Fe) which were electrochemically gen
erated in solution by using 1,4,7-triazacyclononane-based ligands cont
aining one, two, or three p-methoxy or p-tert-butyl N-substituted phen
olates, i.e., ert-butyl-2-hydroxybenzyl)-1,4,7-triazacyclononane (L-3(
but)), 5-methoxy-2-hydroxybenzyl)-1,4,7-triazacyclononane (L-3(met)),
y-2-hydroxybenzyl)-7-ethyl-1,4,7-triazacyclononane L-2(met), and ydrox
ybenzyl)-4,7-dimethyl-1,4,7-triazacyclononane (L-1(met)). A selective
enhancement of the vibrational modes of the phenoxyl chromophores is a
chieved upon excitation in resonance with the pi --> pi transition at
ca. 410 nm. The interpretation of the spectra was supported by quantu
m chemical (density functional theory) calculations which facilitate t
he vibrational assignment for the coordinated phenoxyl radicals and pr
ovide the framework for correlations between the RR spectra and the st
ructural and electronic properties of the radicals. For the uncoordina
ted phenoxyl radicals the geometry optimization yields a semiquinone c
haracter which increases from the unsubstituted to the p-methyl- and t
he p-methoxy-substituted radical. This tendency is indicated by a stea
dy upshift of the nu(8a) mode which predominantly contains the C-ortho
-C-meta stretching coordinate, thereby reflecting strengthening of thi
s bond. The calculated normal-mode frequencies for these radicals are
in a good agreement with the experimental data constituting a sound fo
undation for extending thr vibrational analysis to the 2,6-di-tert-but
yl-4-methoxyphenoxyl which is the building block of the macrocyclic li
gands L-3(met), L-2(met), and L-1(met). The metal-coordinated radical
complexes reveal a similar band pattern as the free radicals with the
modes nu(8a), and nu(7a) (C=O stretching) dominating the RR spectra. T
hese two modes are sensitive spectral indicators for the structural an
d electronic properties of the coordinated phenoxyl radicals. A system
atic investigation of complexes containing different ligands and metal
ions reveals that two parameters control the semiquinone character of
the phenoxyls: (i) an electron-donating substituent in the para posit
ion which can accept spin density from the ring and (ii) an electron-a
ccepting metal ion capable of withdrawing excess electron density, int
roduced by additional electron-donating substituents in ortho position
s. It appears that both effects, which are reflected by (i) the freque
ncy of the mode nu(8a) and (ii) the frequency difference of the modes
nu(8a) and nu(7a), balance an optimum electron density distribution in
the phenoxyl radical. Along similar lines, it has been possible to in
terpret the RR spectral changes between the Fe monoradical, [Fe(L-3(me
t))](+.), and diradical, [Fe(L-3(met))(2+..), complexes. Both the pare
nt as well as the radical complexes of Fe exhibit a phenolate-to-iron
charge transfer band >500 nm. Excitation in resonance with this transi
tion yields a selective enhancement of the vibrational modes of the co
ordinated phenolates which reveal a significantly more complex band pa
ttern than the coordinated phenoxyls. For a large number of phenolate
modes, distinct differences in frequencies and relative intensities we
re found between the parent and the monoradical Fe complexes implying
that oxidation of one phenolate affects the structures and electron de
nsity distributions in the ground and excited states of the remaining
phenolates. These results are discussed in relation to the structure o
f the copper-coordinated tyrosyl radical in the active site of galacto
se oxidase.