A. Kozinski et H. Susman, ORIGINAL MEANINGS - POLITICS AND IDEAS IN THE MAKING OF THE CONSTITUTION - RAKOVE,JN, Stanford law review, 49(6), 1997, pp. 1583-1605
Jack Rakove's Pulitzer prizewinning book Original Meanings will likely
change the terms of the constitutional interpretation debate. As Judg
e Kozinski and Mr. Susman explain, Rakove's book offers a number of in
teresting insights into raging constitutional disputes, In particular
although Original Meanings provides some support for advocates of non-
Article V constitutional change, such as Professors Bruce Ackerman and
Akhil Amar, it cautions against the use of informal procedures. Moreo
ver, Original Meanings presents an intriguing account of the ratificat
ion procedure, focusing on its all-or-nothing character. Kozinski and
Susman argue that this account sounds the death knell for the strict o
riginalist position. Finally, Original Meanings also illustrates the p
otential to hijack various interpretative methods for purely political
purposes.