Acr. Tanner et al., RAPID CHAIR-SIDE DNA-PROBE ASSAY OF BACTEROIDES-FORSYTHUS AND PORPHYROMONAS-GINGIVALIS, Journal of Periodontal Research, 33(2), 1998, pp. 105-117
This study compared a rapid, colorimetric DNA probe assay designed to
be performed in a dental office within 40 min, with anaerobic culture
and indirect immunofluorescence microscopy (IFM) for detection of Bact
eroides forsythus and Porphyromonas gingivalis in subgingival plaque s
amples. The DNA probe assay used the Periodontal Microbial Identificat
ion Test (Saigene Corporation, Bothell, Washington, USA). B. forsythus
was detected in 46 (52%), 49 (55%) and 39 (44%) of the samples by DNA
probe, culture (at levels greater than or equal to 10(5)) and IFM, re
spectively. P. gingivalis was detected in 24 (27%), 18 (20%) and 29 (3
3%) of the samples by DNA probe, culture (at levels greater than or eq
ual to 10(5)) and IFM, respectively. Results from the DNA probe assay
were compared to culture. Culture negative, probe positive samples wer
e re-evaluated by IFM, and IFM positive samples were considered positi
ve in ''resolved'' data. Using resolved data, DNA probe detection sens
itivity and specificity values for B. forsythus were 81% and 91% and f
or P. gingivalis were 80% and 95%, respectively. DNA probe test result
s were further compared with culture and IFM. For samples negative by
both culture and IFM, probe specificity was 92% in 25 B. forsythus sam
ples and 95% in 57 P. gingivalis samples. For samples positive by both
reference methods, probe sensitivity was 82% in 27 B. forsythus sampl
es and 73% in 15 P. gingivalis samples. B. forsythus was detected more
frequently by culture compared with IFM; the reverse was observed for
P. gingivalis. The rapid DNA probe assay for B. forsythus and P. ging
ivalis was comparable to cultivable and IF analyses.