Ph. Guadagnini et al., CORE ELECTRON ENERGIES, INFRARED INTENSITIES, AND ATOMIC CHARGES, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 119(18), 1997, pp. 4224-4231
Carbon 1s electron binding energies determined by X-ray photoelectron
spectroscopy and mean dipole moment derivatives obtained from experime
ntal infrared intensities are shown to be related through the simple p
otential model proposed by Siegbahn and collaborators. The sp(3) carbo
n atoms in 13 halomethanes, 2 ethanes, 3 methylacetylenes, cyclopropan
e, and ethylene oxide have 1s energies, which, after correction for el
ectrostatic potentials from neighboring atoms, are linearly related to
the carbon mean dipole moment derivatives, presenting a slope of 15.5
0 +/- 0.29 eV/e. The sp(2) carbons of ethylene, three haloethylenes, a
nd three carbonyl compounds also exhibit a linear relationship having
a significantly different slope of 17.37 +/- 0.87 eV/e. The sp carbon
atoms in acetylenes, cyanides, CO, CS2 CO2, and OCS show a third linea
r relationship, with a slope of 18.90 +/- 0.75 eV/e. These slopes are
proportional to the inverse atomic radii of sp(3), sp(2), and sp carbo
n atoms and according to the simple potential equation can be interpre
ted as estimates of Coulomb repulsion integrals involving these hybrid
ized orbitals and the 1s core electron orbitals. Two basic assumptions
of the potential model are investigated. The effect of relaxation ene
rgies on the 1s electron ionization processes is estimated as the diff
erence between Delta SCF ionization energies and Koopmans' frozen orbi
tal estimates obtained from 6-31G(d,p) wave functions. These results a
re compared with values obtained previously from the equivalent cores
estimating procedure. Also the conceptual validity of identifying the
carbon mean dipole moment derivatives as atomic charges Is discussed w
ithin the framework of the charge-charge flux-overlap model.