Sm. Machale et al., DEPRESSION AND ITS RELATION TO LESION LOCATION AFTER STROKE, Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery and Psychiatry, 64(3), 1998, pp. 371-374
The study of discrete organic cerebral lesions resulting in clearly de
finable psychiatric disorders may provide an understanding of the unde
rlying pathophysiological basis of these disorders. However, the relat
ion between lesion location and psychiatric illness after stroke remai
ns unclear. Fifty five patients referred to hospital were identified w
ho had a single lesion on CT which was consistent with their neurologi
cal presentation and who did not have evidence of a persistent affecti
ve disorder at the time of the stroke. Six months after stroke standar
dised psychiatric assessment disclosed that 26% of the patients met DS
M-IV criteria for an anxiety or depressive disorder, with depression t
he most common diagnosis (20%). Pathological emotionalism was diagnose
d in 18% of patients, particularly those who were depressed (p<0.0001)
. Depression was significantly associated with larger lesions involvin
g the right cerebral hemisphere (p=0.01). The importance of depression
as a consequence of stroke has been clarified by the studies in this
area. However, wide confidence intervals support the possibility that
significant results may be due to chance. A systematic review of these
studies is now needed if a consensus is to be reached.