N. Brenner, GLOBAL CITIES, GLOCAL STATES - GLOBAL CITY FORMATION AND STATE TERRITORIAL RESTRUCTURING IN CONTEMPORARY EUROPE, Review of international political economy, 5(1), 1998, pp. 1-37
This article examines the changing relationship between global cities
and territorial states in contemporary Europe, and outlines some of it
s implications for the geography of world capitalism in the late twent
ieth century. Most accounts of global cities are based upon a 'zero-su
m' conception of spatial scale that leads to an emphasis on the declin
ing power of the territorial state: as the global scale expands, the s
tate scale is said to contract. By contrast, I view globalization as a
highly contradictory reconfiguration of superimposed spatial scales,
including those on which the territorial state is organized. The state
scale is not being eroded, but rearticulated and reterritorialized in
relation to both sub-and supra-state scales. The resultant, re-scaled
configuration of state territorial organization is provisionally labe
led a 'glocal' state. As nodes of accumulation, global cities are site
s of post-Fordist forms of global industrialization; as coordinates of
state territorial power, global cities are local-regional levels with
in a larger, reterritorialized matrix of increasingly 'glocalized' sta
te institutions. State re-scaling is a major accumulation strategy thr
ough which these transformed 'glocal' territorial states attempt to pr
omote the global competitive advantage of their major urban regions. G
lobal city formation and state re-scaling are therefore dialectically
intertwined moments of a single dynamic of global capitalist restructu
ring. These arguments are illustrated through a discussion of the inte
rface between global cities and territorial states in contemporary Eur
ope, A concluding section argues that new theories and representations
of spatial scale and its social production are needed to grasp the ra
pidly changing political geography of late twentieth-century capitalis
m.