J. Kaarbo, POWER-POLITICS IN FOREIGN-POLICY - THE INFLUENCE OF BUREAUCRATIC MINORITIES, European journal of international relations, 4(1), 1998, pp. 67-97
Scholars of foreign policy-making have concentrated on how the most po
werful domestic actors influence foreign policy and have largely ignor
ed the influence of less powerful, minority actors. This article argue
s that bureaucratic minorities - subordinates and less powerful depart
ments - can and do influence foreign policy. Despite the extensive sch
olarship on bureaucratic politics and the central importance of 'power
' in the theory, we know little about the nature and effects of asymme
trical power relations. Drawing from various research, this article pr
oposes that bureaucratic minorities can adopt strategies based on rewa
rds and costs, manipulation of decision procedures, and information to
bypass or exploit their status to influence policy. The choice and ef
fectiveness of these strategies may depend on whether or not the actor
is a vertical minority (a subordinate influencing a superior) or a ho
rizontal minority (a representative from a less powerful department in
fluencing other departments). Further investigations of the conditions
under which minority players have influence can be part of a much nee
ded revival of the bureaucratic politics perspective on foreign policy
-making.