Previous work shows that the red-green (RG) detection mechanism is hig
hly sensitive, responding to equal and opposite long-wave (L) and midd
le-wave (M) cone contrast signals, This mechanism mediates red-green h
ue judgements under many conditions, We show that the RG detection mec
hanism also receives a weak input from the short-wave (S) cones that s
upports the L signal and equally opposes M, This was demonstrated with
a pedestal paradigm, in which weak S cone flicker facilitates discrim
ination and detection of red-green flicker, Also, a near-threshold +S
cone flash facilitates detection of red flashes and inhibits green fla
shes, and a near-threshold -S cone flash facilitates detection of gree
n flashes and inhibits red flashes. The S contrast weight in RG is sma
ll relative to the L and M contrast weights, However, a comparison of
our results with other studies suggests that the strength of the absol
ute S cone contrast contribution to the RG detection mechanism is 1/4
to 1/3 the strength of the S contribution to the blue-yellow (BY) dete
ction mechanism, Thus, the S weight in RG is a significant fraction of
the S weight in BY, This has important implications for the 'cardinal
' color mechanisms, for it predicts that for detection or discriminati
on, the mechanisms limiting performance do not lie on orthogonal M-L a
nd S axes within the equiluminant color plane. (C) 1998 Elsevier Scien
ce Ltd. All rights reserved.