''Preventable'' hospitalizations have been proposed as indicators of p
oor health plan performance. In this study of elderly Medicare benefic
iaries, however, we found that preventable hospitalizations are also m
ore common among elders of lower socioeconomic status (SES). The relat
ionship persisted even when an up-to-date severity-of-illness adjustme
nt system was used. To the extent that indicators of health plan ''per
formance'' reflect enrollees' characteristics, plans will be rewarded
for marketing their services to wealthier, healthier, and better-educa
ted patients. Further work is needed to clarify issues of accountabili
ty for preventable hospitalizations and other putative indices of heal
th plan performance.