It is a distinctive feature of OT (Prince and Smolensky, 1993) to allo
w for the co-existence in one grammar of perfectly opposite constraint
s. This paper shows that rather than being the uninteresting OT-equiva
lent of the parameters of the Government and Binding tradition (Chomsk
y, 1981), such constraint-pairs make crucial distinctions among the tw
o frameworks. With this goal in mind, I examine the Chadic language Ka
nakuru (Tuller, 1992), arguing that leftward and rightward structural
focus alternate in systematic ways. I then show how such a mixed patte
rn follows precisely from the existence in UG of two constraints speci
fying opposite alignment-directions for structural contrastive focus.
The same constraints are also responsible for the uniform focus patter
ns of languages like Podoko and Italian (Tuller, 1992; Belletti and Sh
lonsky, 1995; Samek-Lodovici, 1996, 1997a).