We study the accuracy of several alternative semiclassical methods by
computing analytically the energy levels for many large classes of exa
ctly solvable shape-invariant potentials. For these potentials, the gr
oundstate energies computed via the WKB method typically deviate from
the exact results by about 10%, a recently suggested modification, usi
ng nonintegral Maslov indices, is substantially better, and the supers
ymmetric WKB quantization method gives exact answers for all energy le
vels.