Aims. To discover satisfaction with treatment decision and the late in
fluences of surgery for early breast cancer on the lives and self-perc
eptions of women. Methods. A two-part mail survey was returned by 90 w
omen aged 2.8-7.6 years after breast-conserving treatment (BCT) and by
56 women aged 3.0-8.0 years after modified radical mastectomy (MRM).
Results. Approximately one-third of all patients felt the information
and time before the treatment decision was inadequate. Most women in b
oth treatment groups had participated in treatment decision-making. Wh
en the surgeon alone had made the choice it did not affect satisfactio
n with the treatment result. Few patients regretted the treatment moda
lity chosen. The majority of patients felt no discomfort in their trea
ted breast, but a quarter of all the women suffered from rib pain. Fif
teen of 52 sexually active women reported of reduced breast pleasure s
ensation in their resected breast. The women in both treatment groups
were asked to score a summary satisfaction index (SSI) on a scale of 0
-10 for seven different areas of life: cosmesis, function, work, home,
recreation/sports, social life and sexuality. SSI was used as a measu
re of quality of life. There was a difference in all these categories
between BCT and MRM groups, the former giving significantly higher val
ues. Post-menopausal women tended to be more satisfied than younger wo
men and women over 70 years showed no difference in satisfaction betwe
en the two treatment modalities. Treatment of early breast cancer caus
ed little morbidity in the long run. After MRM slightly more local sym
ptoms were reported. Conclusions. Most women treated with breast-conse
rving surgery esteemed their life normal or close to normal, giving us
a reason to favour BCT when suitable. For women over 70 years old mas
tectomy remains a viable alternative.