Jw. Brandsma et al., THE EFFECT OF EXERCISES ON WALKING DISTANCE OF PATIENTS WITH INTERMITTENT CLAUDICATION - A STUDY OF RANDOMIZED CLINICAL-TRIALS, Physical therapy, 78(3), 1998, pp. 278-286
Background and Purpose. There is no consensus about the indication for
exercises for patients with intermittent claudication of the lower ex
tremity and the characteristics of an exercise program to improve walk
ing distance. The effect of walking is assessed by a systematic review
of randomized clinical trials. Methods. Literature databases were acc
essed using the relevant key words. The references of identified artic
les were screened for additional studies. A checklist was developed to
screen the studies with respect to the variables of interest. A metho
dological assessment form was developed to assess the methodological q
uality of the studies (maximum possible score: 100). Results. Eighty-t
wo articles were identified, of which 21 studies were considered relev
ant for inclusion in the review. Following the analysis of the article
s, 11 studies were for various reasons eliminated, leaving 10 studies
for the systematic review. The score for methodological quality of the
studies ranged from 47 to 75 ((X) over bar=62.5, SD=8.5). Percentage
of improvement in walking distance or time ranged from 28% to 210% ((X
) over bar=105%, SD=55.8%). Conclusion and Discussion. All studies sho
wed that walking exercises improved walking distance in patients with
intermittent claudication. Further research is needed to determine the
optimal exercise program, the effect of adherence to the treatment pr
otocol, and the duration of the effects following a formal exercise pr
ogram.