Wa. Watson et al., OPIOID TOXICITY RECURRENCE AFTER AN INITIAL RESPONSE TO NALOXONE, Journal of toxicology. Clinical toxicology, 36(1-2), 1998, pp. 11-17
Objective: To determine the frequency and potential predictors of opio
id toxicity recurrence after a response to naloxone in adult Emergency
Department patients. Methods: A retrospective case-control study of n
aloxone-treated patients with opioid toxicity over an 8-year period. B
oth the patient response to naloxone and recurrence of opioid toxicity
was determined by an expert Delphi Panel. The frequency of opioid tox
icity recurrence was compared by the duration of opioid effect, the ro
ute of opioid exposure, and the presence of other CNS depressant drugs
. Results: Ninety of 221 (41%) cases with a discharge diagnosis of opi
oid toxicity were treated with naloxone; six patients were excluded be
cause of a lack of toxicity. There was a response to naloxone in 50% o
f the 84 cases, and recurrence of toxicity in 31% (95% CI 17-45%) of n
aloxone responders. The most common opioids were codeine, heroin, prop
oxyphene, and oxycodone/hydrocodone. Recurrence of toxicity was more c
ommon with long-acting opioids (p = 0.04), and was not associated with
the route of opioid exposure (p = 0.42), or presence of ethanol and o
ther CNS depressants (p greater than or equal to 0.87). Conclusion: Op
ioid toxicity recurrence after a response to naloxone occurred in appr
oximately 1/3 of adult Emergency Department opioid overdose cases. Rec
urrence was more common with long-acting opioids and was not associate
d with the route of opioid exposure. Other clinically useful predictor
s of toxicity recurrence were not identified.