The purpose of the study was to ascertain the influence of subject mat
ter expertise on teachers' pedagogical content knowledge. Data were co
llected through multiple, extended interviews with 10 teachers with ex
pertise in at least 1 subject area in physical education. Each teacher
was interviewed 4 times for approximately 1 hour, focusing on the tea
cher's familiarity with 2 content areas (1 expert and 1 nonexpert) and
their experiences teaching the subjects, Data were analyzed using the
constant comparative technique. The findings were presented nifh refe
rence to Grossman's (1990) definition of pedagogical content knowledge
. Subject experts identified their largest pedagogical problem as stud
ent motivation, while nonexperts believed finding appropriate activiti
es was their greatest challenge. Subject experts were more comfortable
and enthusiastic about pedagogical duties and could accommodate a gre
ater range of abilities. The experts and nonexperts revealed no differ
ences in curricular selection, perceptions of students' understanding
of the subject, or evaluation criteria.