D. Curran et al., QUALITY-OF-LIFE OF EARLY-STAGE BREAST-CANCER PATIENTS TREATED WITH RADICAL-MASTECTOMY OR BREAST-CONSERVING PROCEDURES - RESULTS OF EORTC TRIAL-10801, European journal of cancer, 34(3), 1998, pp. 307-314
In 1980 the EORTC-BCCG initiated a multicentre randomised clinical tri
al comparing modified radical mastectomy (MRM) with breast-conserving
therapy (BCT) in stage I and II breast cancer. The main endpoint of th
e trial was survival. A brief quality of Life (QoL) questionnaire cons
isting of two multi-item scales (body image and fear of recurrence) an
d two single items (satisfaction with treatment and cosmetic result) w
as included in the trial. A cosmetic evaluation of the breast after co
nservative surgery was also performed. This report concentrates on the
results of the QoL study and the cosmetic evaluation. Multitrait scal
ing analysis was employed to verify the hypothesised scale structure o
f the questionnaire. Treatment comparison of the QoL scores at 2 years
post-treatment was performed using a stratified Wilcoxon rank sum tes
t. Both patients' and doctors' ratings of the cosmetic result were doc
umented on the clinical follow-up form. A multivariate analysis was pe
rformed to identify which factors influenced the cosmetic outcome. In
total, 127 patients in the MRM arm and 151 in the BCT arm completed a
QoL questionnaire at approximately 2 years after randomisation (months
25-36). The Cronbach's alpha coefficients were 0.79 and 0.73 for the
body image and fear of recurrence scales, respectively. Significant be
nefit in body image and satisfaction with treatment was observed in th
e BCT patients. No significant difference was observed in fear of recu
rrence between the two groups. Ratings of cosmetic results decreased w
ith time, in line with clinical observations of longterm side-effects
of radiotherapy. Wide excision appeared to be the most important predi
ctive factor for poor cosmetic result. In this multicentre randomised
study, BCT helped to maintain the patients' body image, resulted in hi
gher satisfaction with treatment and yielded no significant difference
from MRM with respect to fear of recurrence. (C) 1998 Elsevier Scienc
e Ltd. All rights reserved.