IMPROVED MOMENT-ESTIMATION FORMULAS USING MORE THAN 3 SUBJECTIVE FRACTILES

Authors
Citation
Hs. Lau et al., IMPROVED MOMENT-ESTIMATION FORMULAS USING MORE THAN 3 SUBJECTIVE FRACTILES, Management science, 44(3), 1998, pp. 346-351
Citations number
21
Categorie Soggetti
Management,"Operatione Research & Management Science","Operatione Research & Management Science
Journal title
ISSN journal
00251909
Volume
44
Issue
3
Year of publication
1998
Pages
346 - 351
Database
ISI
SICI code
0025-1909(1998)44:3<346:IMFUMT>2.0.ZU;2-Z
Abstract
PERT-type subjective estimations are used in many stochastic decision models to estimate the random variables' mean and standard deviation ( s.d.). The approach is based on the beta-distribution assumption; also , mast PERT-type formulas use only three estimated fractiles. We point out that: (if it is desirable to consider a substantially richer set of distributions than the beta in developing PERT-type formulas; (ii) it may be beneficial to use more than three fractile-estimates in PERT -type formulas. We then develop formulas for estimating the mean and s .d. that are based on a substantially richer set of distributions than the beta and that use more than three estimated fractiles. These form ulas perform better than the best currently-available formulas when th e subjective distribution is not restricted to be beta.