D. Simon, RETHINKING (POST)MODERNISM, POSTCOLONIALISM, AND POSTTRADITIONALISM -SOUTH-NORTH PERSPECTIVES, Environment and planning. D. Society & Space, 16(2), 1998, pp. 219-245
Many social scientists and development experts working in the South ha
ve dismissed postmodernism and related perspectives as irrelevant in t
he context of continued poverty and struggles for modernisation. Conve
rsely, Northern authors on postmodernism frequently imply the global s
alience of the paradigm in a universalising manner redolent of moderni
st discourse, whereas critics of conventional development(alism) tend
to base their arguments on caricatures in which the diversity of real-
world experiences and some important improvements in the quality of li
fe over the last 30 years are ignored. Neither approach is tenable, an
d in this paper the author explores the scope and basis for more fruit
ful engagements with postmodernism, postcolonialism, and related persp
ectives, including Southern notions of posttraditionalism, in the cont
ext of current developments and popular aspirations in the South. A cr
itical reading of the literature is combined with examples drawn from
different regions. In the analysis a pathway is offered through these
often confusing fields and the relationships between globalisation, mo
dernisation, and postmodernism, the changing roles and abilities of st
ate and nonstate actors, and the complex ways in which local communiti
es engage with such dynamics in pursuit of a better life, are encompas
sed.