Over the years a large number of dumped and ordered packings have been
developed for effective treatment of material in absorption, desorpti
on, extraction and rectification columns. The task of these column pac
kings is to improve the mass transfer between a liquid phase and a gas
or vapor phase. Furthermore, they also have to assure large throughpu
ts at low pressure drops. When elaborating possible solutions for the
separation of liquid mixtures or for cleaning flows of waste air or wa
ste water in mass transfer columns, the planning engineer repeatedly f
aces the question of which dumped packing or which arranged packing pr
esents the most favorable design from a process engineering standpoint
. In recent years the opinion has often been voiced that arranged pack
ings are always more effective than dumped packings. The purpose of th
is paper is to show that a number of applications exist in which moder
n dumped packings are equal or even superior to arranged packings. On
the basis of selected examples the author discusses when the use of a
structured packing is preferable with regard to process engineering.