C. Matthis et al., THE EUROPEAN VERTEBRAL OSTEOPOROSIS STUDY (EVOS) - PARTICIPATION BEHAVIOR AND SELECTION BIAS IN GERMANY, Medizinische Klinik, 93, 1998, pp. 18-25
Background: In population-based studies non-participation rates of abo
ut one third of the sample can be expected. The number of refusals may
even be higher, if personal attendence of the subjects is requested.
A different participation behaviour of the diseased and non-diseased m
ay affect the prevalence estimation of a disease as well as the risk f
actor association. Methods and Results: The European Vertebral Osteopo
rosis Study (EVOS) is an international, multicenter, cross-sectional s
urvey in men and women aged 50 to 79 years. Within Europe 36 centres r
ecruited 17 342 participants. The 8 German centres contribute about on
e fourth of the data. In Germany subjects were recruited in several st
eps: random sample drawing from population registries, initial postal
questionnaire, medical interview, lateral X-rays of the thoracic and l
umbar spine. Depending on the extent of participation a variable amoun
t of sociodemographic data and information on subjective health is ava
ilable from the nonreachable, non-responders, and responders with inco
mplete and with complete examination. A comparison of the different pa
rticipation groups showed, that especially old women were lost from th
e study, Compared to those, who only answered to an initial questionna
ire, subjects, who were interviewed and X-rayed, more often suffered f
rom back pain but reported a better functional capacity. This could be
a hint on a selection of a population of the ''worried well''. Conclu
sion: On the whole the selection processes seem to have a minor influe
nce on the outcome. The initial postal questionnaire turned out to be
effective in collecting basic information from those who refused to at
tend a personal examination.