M. Steiner et Ra. Houze, SENSITIVITY OF MONTHLY 3-DIMENSIONAL RADAR-ECHO CHARACTERISTICS TO SAMPLING FREQUENCY, Journal of the Meteorological Society of Japan, 76(1), 1998, pp. 73-95
Estimates of any precipitation characteristics based on temporally spa
rse observations entail uncertainty because of the natural variability
of rainfall in space and time. This study measures the sampling-relat
ed uncertainties of monthly mean reflectivity profile and surface rain
fall distribution. Radar and rain gauge data collected during the 1993
/94 monsoon season at Darwin, Australia, are used to show the sensitiv
ity of monthly three-dimensional radar-echo and precipitation characte
ristics to the frequency of observation. The data are partitioned into
convective, stratiform, and anvil components according to the horizon
tal and vertical structure of the echoes. The analyses of this study r
eveal the expected trend that the uncertainties of estimated precipita
tion characteristics using infrequent observations scale with rainfall
amount. The results have implications for climatological studies usin
g spaceborne observation platforms revisiting a given area intermitten
tly. The Tropical Rainfall Measuring Mission (TRMM) satellite radar, w
hich will revisit a given 500 km by 500 km region approximately twice
daily, will likely encounter significant problems in estimating the ve
rtical profile of radar reflectivity in the tropics. Monthly mean refl
ectivity statistics (based on observations within 150 km of the Darwin
radar) exhibit a sampling-related uncertainty of about 20 % in both r
ain and snow. In addition, the radar signal of the TRMM satellite will
be highly attenuated below the 0 degrees C level, and the precipitati
on radar will be insensitive to reflectivity less than about 20 dBZ. T
herefore, the spaceborne radar will have an obscured view of the verti
cal precipitation structure. Reliable reflectivity statistics based on
TRMM satellite radar data may be obtained primarily within an altitud
e range of about 5-7.5 km-an altitude range though that is important f
or cloud electrification because of the mixed-phase precipitation proc
esses taking place there. The sampling uncertainty, signal attenuation
, and radar sensitivity vary with precipitation type. Moreover, estima
tion of the convective rain fraction will be compromised by uncertaint
ies in the echo classification as well as a choice of Z - R relation.
These results imply the importance of information collected by ground
validation site radars to improve upon TRMM satellite estimates of pre
cipitation characteristics and the derived vertical profile of latent
heating.