Tp. Wagner et Tl. Grove, MELT HARZBURGITE REACTION IN THE PETROGENESIS OF THOLEIITIC MAGMA FROM KILAUEA VOLCANO, HAWAII/, Contributions to Mineralogy and Petrology, 131(1), 1998, pp. 1-12
We use the results of elevated pressure melting experiments to constra
in the role of melt/mantle reaction in the formation of tholeiitic mag
ma from Kilauea volcano, Hawaii. Trace element abundance data is commo
nly interpreted as evidence that Kilauea tholeiite is produced by part
ial melting of garnet Iherzolite. We experimentally determine the liqu
idus relations of a tightly constrained estimate of primary tholeiite
composition, and find that it is not in equilibrium on its liquidus wi
th a garnet Iherzolite assemblage at any pressure. The composition is,
however, cosaturated on its liquidus with olivine and orthopyroxene a
t 1.4 GPa and 1425 degrees C, from which we infer that primary tholeii
te is in equilibrium with harzburgite at lithospheric depths beneath K
ilauea. These results are consistent with our observation that tholeii
te primary magmas have higher normative silica contents than experimen
tally produced melts of garnet Iherzolite. A model is presented whereb
y primary tholeiite forms via a two-stage process. In the first stage,
magmas are generated by melting of garnet lherzolite in a mantle plum
e. In the second stage, the ascent and decompression of magmas causes
them to react with harzburgite in the mantle by assimilating orthopyro
xene and crystallizing olivine. This reaction can produce typical thol
eiite primary magmas from significantly less siliceous garnet Iherzoli
te melts, and is consistent with the shift in liquidus boundaries that
accompanies decompression of an ascending magma. We determine the pro
portion of reactants by major element mass balance. The ratio of mass
assimilated to mass crystallized (M-a/M-c) varies from 2.7 to 1.4, dep
ending on the primary magma composition. We use an AFC calculation to
model the effect of melt/harzburgite reaction on melt rare earth and h
igh field strength element abundances, and find that reaction dilutes,
but does not significantly fractionate, the abundances of these eleme
nts. Assuming olivine and orthopyroxene have similar heats of fusion,
the M-a/M-c ratio indicates that reaction is endothermic. The addition
al thermal energy is supplied by the melt, which becomes superheated d
uring adiabatic ascent and can provide more thermal energy than requir
ed. Melt/ harzburgite reaction likely occurs over a range of depths, a
nd we infer a mean depth of 42 km from our experimental results. This
depth is well within the lithosphere beneath Kilauea. Since geochemica
l evidence indicates that melt/harzburgite reaction likely occurs in t
he top of the Hawaiian plume, the plume must be able to thin a signifi
cant portion of the lithosphere.