Thirty-seven patients with 20 cemented Thompson-Richards prostheses an
d 19 cementless S.T.A.R. prostheses (2 bilateral cases) were followed
up after 1-12 years. Rheumatoid arthritis was the main diagnosis in bo
th populations, with females dominating. The investigation was based o
n the Kofoed ankle score. At follow-up the total scoring improved to 8
6.9 pts. in S.T.A.R. and to 77.7 pts, in T.R.P. replacement. The radio
logical examination showed a high rate of radiolucency for the tibial
component (53.3%) in cemented T.R.P.; subsidence of talar component wa
s seen in 3 cases with T.R.P. In cementless S.T.A.R. prosthesis only 3
cases showed small radiolucent lines of the flat tibial component. Ta
lar subsidence was not seen at all. In T.R.P. we had two revisions due
to prosthesis loosening and one malleolar fracture, giving a cumulati
ve estimated survival rate of 87% at 12 years. In the S.T.A.R. prosthe
sis group two revisions had to be performed because of one meniscal br
eakage and correction of meniscal height. The estimated survival rate
at 6 years was 94.3%.