Diesel particles form a large component of the fine particle fraction
(PM10) in urban air in the UK. During pollution episodes small increas
es in PM10 have been linked to detrimental health effects. The compara
tive toxicological effects of diesel exhaust and other well-characteri
sed particles (carbon black, amorphous and crystalline silica) on rat
respiratory epithelium were investigated in the present study. The eff
ects of small masses of particles (1 mg) delivered by intratracheal in
stillation were monitored by changes in components of lavage fluid. Re
spirable, crystalline quartz, produced significant increases in lung p
ermeability, persistent surface inflammation, progressive increases in
pulmonary surfactant and activities of epithelial marker enzymes up t
o 12 weeks after primary exposure. Ultrafine amorphous silica did not
induce progressive effects but it promoted initial epithelial damage w
ith permeability changes and these regressed with time after exposure.
By contrast, ultrafine/fine carbon black had little, if any, effect o
n lung permeability, epithelial markers or inflammation, despite being
given at a dose which readily translocated the epithelium and which h
as been reported to induce inflammation. Similarly, diesel exhaust par
ticles produced only minimal changes in lavage components, although th
ey were smaller individual particles and differed in surface chemistry
from carbon black. It is concluded that diesel exhaust particles are
less damaging to respiratory epithelium than silicon dioxide and that
the surface chemistry of a particle is more important than ultrafine s
ize in explaining its biological reactivity.