To determine the effects of ingestion by birds on seed germination, we
performed germination experiments in the field and laboratory with So
rbus commixta. The germination of four groups of seeds was compared: i
ngested seeds, seeds defecated in feces after feeding of fruits to bir
ds; extracted seeds, seeds deliberately extracted from the fruit pulp;
juiced seeds, seeds plus the juice of the pulp after seeds had been d
eliberately extracted from the pulp; intact seeds, seeds in untreated
intact fruits. In the laboratory, intact and juiced seeds hardly germi
nated, but ingested and extracted seeds germinated. Thus, the pulp and
its juice appeared to inhibit germination, but seeds could germinate
without ingestion by birds once the seeds had been manually extracted
from the pulp. In the field, intact fruits did not germinate in the fi
rst spring, because the seed was still covered with pulp. The pulp of
intact seeds decomposed during the first summer, and thus, the seeds h
ad the potential to germinate during the second spring. In fact, most
intact seeds do not germinate during the second spring either, since t
hey lose their viability during the first summer. Thus, under natural
conditions, most seeds of Sorbus commixta cannot germinate without bir
d ingestion.