Cationic lipid-DNA complexes (lipoplexes) have been widely used as gen
e transfer vectors which avoid the adverse immunogenicity and potentia
l for viraemia of viral vectors. With the long-term aim of gene transf
er into skeletal muscle in vivo, we describe a direct in vitro compari
son of two commercially available cationic lipid formulations, Lipofec
tamine and DOSPER. Optimisation of transfection was performed in the C
2C12 mouse muscle cell line, before further studies in primary mouse m
yoblasts and C2C12 myotubes. Reporter gene constructs expressing eithe
r E. coli beta-galactosidase or green fluorescent protein (GFP) were u
sed in order to evaluate transfection efficiency by histochemical stai
ning or FACS analysis, respectively. Both lipid formulations were able
to promote efficient, reproducible gene transfer in C2C12 cells, and
to transfect primary mouse myoblast cultures successfully. However, DO
SPER exhibited the important advantage of being able to transfect cell
s in the presence of serum of both bovine and murine origin. This feat
ure allowed increased cell survival during in vitro transfections, and
may be advantageous for direct in vivo gene transfer efficacy.