It is argued here that Georg Simmel's essay on the stranger resonated
with or directly influenced all major German sociologists of his time:
Max Weber, Werner Sombart, Ferdinand Tonnies, and Robert Michels. Soo
n thereafter, the Chicago School, in particular Robert Park and Everet
t Hughes, transposed Simmel's idea as ''marginal man'' into American s
ociology. In contrast to Simmel, however, who defined the stranger as
one who ''comes today and stays tomorrow,'' and also in contrast to th
e American literature, his German contemporaries saw the stranger as a
temporary and unassimilable intruder. After the Holocaust, beginning
with Lewis Coser, and mostly in Germany, Simmel's essay and Simmel's b
iography experience a reading which construct Simmel as a Jewish stran
ger isolated from his surroundings. In light of Simmel's actual, highl
y integrated, social position in the Germany of his time, this view is
untenable.