DISTANCED PERSPECTIVES - AIDS, ANENCEPHALY, AND AHP

Authors
Citation
T. Koch et M. Ridgley, DISTANCED PERSPECTIVES - AIDS, ANENCEPHALY, AND AHP, THEORETICAL MEDICINE AND BIOETHICS, 19(1), 1998, pp. 47-58
Citations number
33
Categorie Soggetti
Social Issues","Medicine, Legal
ISSN journal
13867415
Volume
19
Issue
1
Year of publication
1998
Pages
47 - 58
Database
ISI
SICI code
1386-7415(1998)19:1<47:DP-AAA>2.0.ZU;2-Y
Abstract
US court decisions guaranteeing life-sustaining care to anencephalic i nfants have been viewed with disfavor, and sometimes disbelief, by som e ethicists who do not believe in the necessity of life-sustaining sup port for those without cognitive abilities or an independently sustain able future. The distance between these two views - one legal and incl usive, the other medical and specific - seems unbridgeable. This paper reports on a program using multicriterion decision making to define a nd describe persons in a way which both acknowledges the differences p erceived by many as well as those commonalities insisted on in U.S. co urt decisions. It does this through application of the Analytic Hierar chy Process to a hierarchy of ''humanness'' criteria, and secondarily through reference to that concept's subset, personhood.