M. Llunell et al., SKUTTERUDITE VS. REO3 STRUCTURES FOR MX3 SOLIDS - ELECTRONIC REQUIREMENTS, Journal of the Chemical Society. Dalton transactions, (7), 1998, pp. 1195-1200
Electronic band-structure calculations on ReO3 and CoP3 have been perf
ormed to analyse the different structural preferences found for these
two compounds. The electronic origin of these differences is associate
d with the formation of the characteristic non-metal four-membered rin
gs of the skutterudite structure, which is energetically unfavorable f
or compounds with small, strongly electronegative anions. The combinat
ion of two factors has been identified to be responsible for the struc
tural differences between these compounds. The first is the electroneg
ativity difference between the two types of atoms that form the solid:
for strongly electronegative non-metal atoms like O or F the ReO3-typ
e structure is expected to be the most stable, while for the combinati
on of less electronegative atoms like the pnictides with late transiti
on metals the skutterudite structure is preferred. The second factor i
s the relative size of the constituting atoms: small atoms like F and
O favor the ReO, structure, while larger atoms like P and As stabilize
the skutterudite one.