Bj. Edwards et al., ON THE RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN THERMODYNAMIC FORMALISMS FOR COMPLEX FLUIDS, Journal of non-equilibrium thermodynamics, 22(4), 1997, pp. 356-373
In recent years, several seemingly distinct approaches have been devel
oped which aim to describe the mechanics and thermodynamics of complex
fluids under dynamical conditions. Two of these approaches of decided
ly different flavor are the Matrix Model of thermodynamically driven s
ystems developed by Jongschaap and the GENERIC formalism of Grmela and
Ottinger. Herein, we examine the interrelationships between these two
alternate approaches on an abstract level and work out direct connect
ions for two specific examples of thermodynamically driven systems: a
gas housed in a cylinder closed by a piston subject to external force
and potential fields, and a dilute solution of Hookean dumbbells in a
Bow field. It is demonstrated that the Matrix Model derives from the G
ENERIC formalism when the global thermodynamic system is split into tw
o parts: a smaller open thermodynamic system with fewer internal varia
bles, and its environment composed of external driving forces which ar
e determined from the variables which are neglected in the smaller sys
tem. Thus the Matrix Model provides an explicit answer to the question
of how to handle driven systems within the more global GENERIC formal
ism. It is also shown that the Matrix Model requires a prerequisite kn
owledge of the laws of motion for a given system, whereas these are ex
plicitly embedded in the GENERIC structure.