Ed. Rhine et al., IMPROVING THE BERTHELOT REACTION FOR DETERMINING AMMONIUM IN SOIL EXTRACTS AND WATER, Soil Science Society of America journal, 62(2), 1998, pp. 473-480
Colorimetric methods based on the Berthelot reaction are used widely f
or quantitative determination of NH4-N in biological and environmental
samples. Studies to evaluate phenol and salicylate, the most commonly
used chromogenic substrates, revealed minor interferences by metallic
cations, whereas up to a threefold shift in absorbance was observed w
ith 38 diverse N-containing organic compounds. Interferences differed
markedly between phenol and salicylate. The possibility of a simple co
rrection was precluded by the fact that interferences were both positi
ve and negative, and depended on the temperature during color developm
ent and the concentration of NH4-N. Fourteen compounds were evaluated
as alternatives to phenol and salicylate, of which the Na salt of 2-ph
enylphenol (PPS) proved to be the most promising. Using PPS, macro-and
microscale batch methods and an automated flow-injection method were
developed. These methods are simple, convenient, and sensitive. Using
the PPS microscale method, for which the limit of detection is 0.17 mg
NH4-N L-1, recovery of NH4-N added to soil extracts ranged from 98 to
104%, with a coefficient of variation of 1.4 to 2.7%. As with phenol
and salicylate, precipitation of metal hydroxides was observed. Precip
itation was controlled by chelation with citrate rather than ethylened
iaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA), which suppressed color development by p
reventing monochloramine formation. Compared with Berthelot methods th
at use phenol or salicylate, interference by amino acids was decreased
by up to 10-fold. Interference by other organic N compounds was virtu
ally eliminated.