EVIDENCE FOR THE OCCURRENCE OF SIBLING SPECIES IN EUBAZUS SPP (HYMENOPTERA, BRACONIDAE), PARASITOIDS OF PISSODES SPP WEEVILS (COLEOPTERA, CURCULIONIDAE)
M. Kenis et Nj. Mills, EVIDENCE FOR THE OCCURRENCE OF SIBLING SPECIES IN EUBAZUS SPP (HYMENOPTERA, BRACONIDAE), PARASITOIDS OF PISSODES SPP WEEVILS (COLEOPTERA, CURCULIONIDAE), Bulletin of entomological research, 88(2), 1998, pp. 149-163
Comparative studies were made on three presumed sibling species of the
genus Eubazus, parasitoids of European Pissodes spp. weevils, to clar
ify their taxonomy and define diagnostic characters. Several populatio
ns of E. semirugosus (Nees), E. robustus (Ratzeburg) and Eubazus sp. w
ere compared with respect to their morphology (mainly through morphome
tric analyses), fecundity, isoenzyme patterns and host preference. Cro
sses were made to assess the genetic and behavioural compatibility of
the populations. In addition, the North American E. crassigaster (Prov
ancher), a parasitoid of Pissodes strobi (Peck), was compared to E. se
mirugosus, a species selected for introduction against P. strobi in Ca
nada. The ratio of the length of the ovipositor sheath to the fore win
g length was the most discriminating morphometric variable, but discri
minant analyses including several measurements were needed to complete
ly separate European species. A canonical discriminant function provid
ed a total separation between males of E. crassigaster and E. semirugo
sus, but not between females. Eubazus crassigaster and E. semirugosus
were totally separated by the banding pattern of the enzyme phosphoglu
conate dehydrogenase whereas hexokinase and esterase provided a diagno
stic separation between Eubazus sp. and E. robustus. Eubazus sp. diffe
red from all the other species by having a greater number of ovarioles
and, consequently, a higher potential fecundity. Ln a two-choice ovip
osition test, E. semirugosus and Eubazus sp. showed a significant pref
erence for their natural host, P. castaneus De Geer and P. piceae (Ill
iger), respectively. A similar test made with their progenies reared u
nder standard conditions showed that the difference in host preference
was genetically fixed. Males and females of different species did not
mate readily, in contrast to individuals from the same species. All a
ttempts to interbreed E. robustus and Eubazus sp. failed, but a few cr
osses between E. semirugosus and the two other European species produc
ed fertile offspring. These observations strongly suggest that the com
plex of Eubazus spp. parasitoids attacking Pissodes spp. in Europe is
composed of at least three sibling species, two of which appear to hav
e specialized on distinct host species that occupy exclusive microhabi
tats.