The rigid unit mode analysis was initially developed to understand the
phase transitions in aluminosilicate minerals containing corner-linke
d tetrahedra. Here the model is applied to a range of minerals with cr
ystal structures that can be described as frameworks of linked octahed
ral and tetrahedral units, including garnet, sillimanite, titanite, an
d ellenbergerite. Consistent with a constraint analysis, there are no
rigid unit modes in these minerals. Generalizing these results suggest
s that there will not be any easy ways to distort structures that have
frameworks containing octahedral units. This result explains why poly
hedral-tilting displacive phase transitions are not common in such min
erals, whereas they occur in most aluminosilicate minerals containing
only tetrahedral units. It also explains that it will be necessary for
the tetrahedra and octahedra to distort when solid solutions are form
ed.