Extensive methylation of the Ubi1 promoter has been shown to be associ
ated with transcriptional silencing and bialaphos herbicide sensitivit
y in several R-1 progeny derived from a transgenic rice line, JKA 52,
containing multiple copies of the introduced genes (Kumpatla at al., 1
997; Plant Physiol. 115, 361-373). All of the progeny from silenced R-
1 lines were silenced, and a proportion (24%) of the R-2 seedlings fro
m JKA 52-6, a non-silenced homozygous R-1 line, were found to be silen
ced. Several non-silenced (bialaphos-resistant) R-2 progeny derived fr
om the selfed seed of JKA 52-6 were tested at various stages throughou
t the growth period and found to be resistant to bialaphos, indicating
the absence of silencing. Five of these were investigated further to
determine whether silencing could recur in subsequent generations. R-3
seedlings were raised from selfed R-2 Seed and herbicide sensitivity
was detected in 5-40% of the plants in three of the five lines. This s
ilencing was accompanied by methylation of the Ubi1 promoter and the a
bsence of steady-state bar mRNA. This recurrent onset of silencing and
instability of expression associated with a transgene locus containin
g several repeated sequences is undesirable. The data strongly suggest
that multi-generation molecular analysis should be undertaken for tra
nsgenic lines to be used for agricultural purposes and that lines cont
aining methylated inserts should be carefully evaluated before being i
ncluded in further breeding strategies.