P. Garrard et al., CATEGORY-SPECIFIC SEMANTIC LOSS IN DEMENTIA OF ALZHEIMERS TYPE - FUNCTIONAL-ANATOMICAL CORRELATIONS FROM CROSS-SECTIONAL ANALYSES, Brain, 121, 1998, pp. 633-646
In the context of focal brain injury, selective loss of semantic knowl
edge in the domain of either natural kinds or artefacts is usually con
sidered to reflect the differential importance of temporal and frontop
arietal regions to the representations of perceptual and functional at
tributes, respectively. It is harder to account for as a feature of a
more diffuse process, and previous cross-sectional analyses of patient
s with dementia of Alzheimer's type (DAT) have differed over whether c
ategory effects occur. In our series of 58 patients with probable DAT,
we demonstrated a significant group advantage for artefacts, and expl
ored possible reasons for the inconsistency of this finding in other s
tudies. A multiple single-case strategy revealed not only individuals
with consistent advantages for artefacts but also individuals with con
sistent advantages for natural kinds. By ranking the individuals accor
ding to measures of naming performance and global intellectual ability
we showed that the strength of the group advantage for artefacts was
dependent on the former brit not the latter variable. The findings are
discussed in the context of two competing theories of semantic breakd
own in DAT. One differentiates between domains of knowledge in terms o
f the structure of semantic representations within a single distribute
d network; the other emphasizes the importance of different brain regi
ons in the category distinction. We conclude that our findings are in
keeping with the predictions of the latter hypothesis.