M. Strupp et al., PERCEPTUAL AND OCULOMOTOR EFFECTS OF NECK MUSCLE VIBRATION IN VESTIBULAR NEURITIS - IPSILATERAL SOMATOSENSORY SUBSTITUTION OF VESTIBULAR FUNCTION, Brain, 121, 1998, pp. 677-685
Afferent cervical somatosensory input may substitute for absent vestib
ular information as part of central vestibular compensation after unil
ateral peripheral vestibular deficit. In order to determine the partic
ular contribution of neck muscle spindles to the perception of body or
ientation and to the oculomotor system, we measured (i) the subjective
visual straight ahead (SVA) by psychophysical rests and (ii) the chan
ges in eye position by video-nystagmography during unilateral stimulat
ion of the posterior neck muscles by vibration (100 Hz). Twenty-five p
atients with subacute unilateral vestibular lesion (vestibular neuriti
s) and 25 controls participated in the study. Vibration elicited a hor
izontal displacement of SVA towards the side of stimulation in all sub
jects. Mean displacement (+/- SD) was 3.28 +/- 2.96 degrees for right-
side and 3.45 +/- 2.93 degrees for left-side stimulation in controls.
Muscle stimulation on the patients' lesion side induced a significantl
y higher displacement (11.51 +/- 6.63 degrees) than contralateral stim
ulation (3.04 +/- 2.95 degrees, P < 0.01, paired Student's t test). Th
e mean difference during stimulation between the two sides in the pati
ents was 8.02 +/- 5.52 degrees; in the controls, however it was only 0
.74 +/- 0.47 degrees (P < 0.001, Student's t test). This asymmetry inc
reased gradually in patients over a period of weeks, reaching a maximu
m at days 60-80 and declining thereafter: Video-nystagmography reveale
d that ipsilateral stimulation in patients induced large horizontal ey
e deviations of up to 25 degrees towards the side of the lesion (9.1 /- 7.6 degrees, n = 18). Contralateral stimulation induced only small
shifts, which were within the range of controls. The correlation coeff
icient between displacement of the SVA and change in eye position was
high (r = 0.94, P < 0.0001), indicating that the shift of SVA is the p
erceptual correlate of the directional change of gaze in space. This i
nterpretation was supported by two control experiments in which the su
bject was required to (i) indicate the subjective straight ahead by fi
nger-painting with the eyes closed and (ii) adjust SVA when looking th
rough horizontally reversing prisms. Vibration of neck muscles caused
almost no displacement of the SVA when it was indicated by pointing wi
th the eyes closed, but reversed the direction of the displacement if
the subject wore reversing prisms. In summary, our data showed: (i) an
increase in muscle spindle input following unilateral vestibular lesi
on; (ii) this increase is asymmetrical, restricted to the affected sid
e, and gradually builds up over weeks; and (iii) the perceived effects
during vibration are secondary to changes in eye position rather than
changes in cortical representation of body orientation. This is the f
irst study to demonstrate a unilateral increase in somatosensory weigh
t, which substitutes for missing vestibular input.