Aqueous extracts of five mine soil samples and a set of selenite (SeO3
2-)-selenate (SeO42-) solutions (0.5, 1, 5, 10 and 25 mg/l) were speci
ated using atomic absorption spectroscopy with hydride generation (AAS
-HG) and ion chromatography (IC) to compare these methods for Se speci
ation. In another experiment, a SeO32--SeO42--SO42- solution (25 mg/l)
was reacted with CaO, MgO, MnO2, CuO, La2O3, and WO3 to evaluate the
relative distribution of the Se species and SO42- in the SORB (sorbed
ions that were desorbed by NaOH), SOLN (equilibrium concentrations), C
MPX (irreversibly sorbed and neutral ion pair complexes) fractions. Th
e AAS-HG method was capable of analyzing Se as low as 0.002 mg/l, whic
h was below the detection limit of IC. High concentration of SO42- aff
ected the chromatographic Se Speciation either by shifting or overlapp
ing Se peaks, in which AAS-HG was more useful. However, IC was capable
of speciating aqueous SeO32--SeO42- directly without any sample pretr
eatment, whereas AAS-HG measured SeO32-+SeO42-, and SeO32- in separate
runs and SeO42- was calculated from the difference, i.e., spectrophot
ometric speciation was an indirect method. For both Se species, AAS-HG
and IC data were comparable within detection standard deviations. Rat
ios of different Se species at measured soil pH and pe indicated that
SeO32- or SeO42- would be the dominant Se species; the p(SeO42-/SeO32-
) values further suggested SeO42- would be the major solution species.
Except for CaO and MgO treatments, the %SeO32- in the SORB fraction w
as greater than or equal to%SeO42-. In the SOLN fraction %SeO42- was g
reater than or equal to%SeO32- for all oxides but CaO, whereas in the
CMPX fraction this order was observed for only CaO and MnO2. The %SeO3
2- was highest in the SOLN fraction for all oxides but MgO and La2O3 f
or these two oxides SeO32- dominated in CMPX and SORB fractions, respe
ctively. The SOLN fraction also contained the highest %SeO42- for all
oxides but MgO which retained SeO42- primarily in the SORB fraction. T
he %SeO32- and %SeO42- in the CMPX fraction were highest for MgO, thus
, suggesting a possible formation of MgSeO30 and MgSeO40. A similar tr
end of SORB %SO42- and SORB %SeO42- was attributed to the analogous ad
sorption mechanisms (outer-sphere complexation). For all oxides but Mg
O, %SO42- was <%SeO42- in the SOLN fraction and greater than or equal
to%SeO42- in the CMPX fraction. Comparative ionic distributions provid
e an overall picture of the relative abundance of different Se species
in various fractions associated with different oxides present in micr
o- and macrolevels in soils and geological materials.