More than two hundred aerobic continental margin, aerobic deep sea, dy
saerobic, and anaerobic/euxinic sediments have been examined for their
variations in different operationally defined iron fractions, each of
which represents a different reactivity toward dissolved sulfide. Aer
obic continental margin, deep sea, and dysaerobic sediments contain si
milar contents of highly reactive iron (dithionite-soluble iron plus p
yrite iron), poorly reactive iron (iron soluble in HCl less that solub
le in dithionite), and unreactive iron (total iron less that soluble i
n HCl). By contrast non-turbidite euxinic samples from the Black Sea,
as well as euxinic samples from the Cariaco Basin and Framvaren are en
riched in highly reactive iron. These sediments contain a small lithog
enous fraction and a Targe biogenous, organic C-rich fraction, which d
ecays by sulfate reduction in an iron-rich water column to form pyrite
-rich sediment. Other anaerobic/euxinic samples from the Black Sea, Or
ca Basin, and Kau Bay contain lower concentrations of biogenous sedime
nt and are not therefore enriched in highly reactive iron. Degrees of
Pyritization (DOP) for all the aerobic, dysaerobic, and anaerobic/euxi
nic samples (except those low in biogenous material) are consistent wi
th analogous ancient sediments and indicate that most pyrite formation
occurs from the highly reactive iron fraction.