Differentiation of gamma delta and alpha beta T cells from a common pr
ecursor cell depends on productive rearrangement and expression of TCR
gamma delta or TCR beta genes, but whether it is an instructive or a
stochastic mechanism that is responsible for this process is unclear.
We report that expression of the productively rearranged TCR gamma tra
nsgene competitively inhibits alpha beta thymocyte development under c
onditions where TCR beta gene rearrangement is limiting. The status of
TCR delta gene rearrangements in the remaining alpha beta-lineage cel
ls indicates that the effect is mediated by the intact gamma delta rec
eptor. Paradoxically, in TCR beta(-/-) mice, gamma delta receptor expr
ession can also drive differentiation of some up-lineage cells. To res
olve this paradox, we provide evidence for a minor population of gamma
delta-dependent alpha beta-lineage cells in normal mice. The results
indicate that the T cell lineage commitment process is either error-pr
one or stochastic.