S. Jequier et al., ACUTE CHILDHOOD PYELONEPHRITIS - PREDICTIVE VALUE OF POSITIVE SONOGRAPHIC FINDINGS IN REGARD TO LATER PARENCHYMAL SCARRING, Academic radiology, 5(5), 1998, pp. 344-353
Rationale and Objectives. The authors evaluated the importance of posi
tive sonographic findings in acute childhood pyelonephritis. Materials
and Methods, A total of 290 children (91 boys, 199 girls, aged 4 days
to 15 years [median, 394 days]) with clinically suspected acute pyelo
nephritis underwent initial renal gray-scale ultrasound (US) and dimer
captosuccinate scintigraphic examination within 3 days of onset. A tot
al of 173 patients underwent color or energy US examination. One hundr
ed fifteen children with normal scintigraphic or pathologic findings (
other than acute pyelonephritis) were excluded from further study; 170
patients with abnormal scintigraphic findings underwent follow-up sci
ntigraphic scanning 60-90 days later. Results. When pathologic structu
res other than acute pyelonephritis were not considered, the diagnosti
c value of gray-scale US was poor, with a sensitivity of 45.5%, a spec
ificity of 86.6%, a positive predictive value of 88.8%, and a negative
predictive value of only 40.6%. In regard to future renal scarring, g
ray-scale US had a positive predictive value of 67.7%, a negative pred
ictive value of 40%, and a likelihood ratio of 1.16. Abnormal Doppler
findings helped predict future scarring with a positive predictive val
ue of 85.7%, a negative predictive value of 37.2%, a very low sensitiv
ity of 26.9%, a high specificity of 90.6%, and a likelihood ratio of 2
.87. Conclusion. Positive US Doppler findings in children with clinica
lly suspected acute pyelonephritis indicate the need for immediate tre
atment. A positive initial gray-scale US examination does not predict
future renal scarring, but a positive Doppler examination indicates a
high probability of scarring. Negative gay-scale or Doppler US does no
t exclude a diagnosis of acute pyelonephritis and it cannot predict an
absence of future scarring.