Pj. Plourde et al., ACCURACY AND COSTS OF RAPID HUMAN-IMMUNODEFICIENCY-VIRUS TESTING TECHNOLOGIES IN RURAL HOSPITALS IN ZAMBIA, Sexually transmitted diseases, 25(5), 1998, pp. 254-259
Objective: To evaluate the accuracy and costs of newer rapid human imm
unodeficiency virus (HIV) antibody tests in primary health care settin
gs in rural Zambia, Methods: Three rural hospitals participated in thi
s study. During a baseline assessment period, HIV testing practices we
re recorded on 250 consecutive clients at each hospital. Baseline eval
uation was compared with 250 subsequent consecutive clients tested usi
ng a testing algorithm consisting of an initial screening HIV Dipstick
test (McDonald Scientific [PVT] Limited, Harare, Zimbabwe) followed b
y confirmatory testing of all reactive specimens using the HIV Capillu
s test (Cambridge Diagnostics, Galway, Ireland), in conformity with Wo
rld Health Organization HIV testing recommendations. Quality control w
as performed at a national university teaching hospital laboratory. Re
sults: A total of 1,500 clients was entered, with an HIV seropositivit
y rate of 53.2%. Most HIV testing was performed on patients with signs
and symptoms suggestive of HIV infection. Same-day results were provi
ded for only 16%. The HIV Dipstick testing algorithm sensitivity was 9
6.9%, and specificity was 98.0%. Counselor dissatisfaction was greater
with the Dipstick algorithm as a result of 5.3% discordant results. U
se of the HIV Dipstick testing algorithm cost between US$3.00 and US$3
.80 per client tested. Conclusions: The accuracy of HIV testing in uns
ophisticated rural laboratories in Zambia is acceptable. Although BTV
Dipstick testing algorithm costs were relatively high for a developing
country, this HIV testing procedure is currently the most economical
method available in Zambia. Accurate, less costly HIV testing algorith
ms are still needed.