Ed. Nelson et al., GAS-PHASE REACTIVITY OF THE 2,6-DIMETHYLENEPYRIDINIUM AND 3,5-DIMETHYLENEPYRIDINIUM BIRADICALS, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 120(15), 1998, pp. 3792-3798
The 2,6- and 3,5-dimethylenepyridinium biradical ions were generated a
nd structurally characterized in the gas phase by using Fourier transf
orm ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry. Their reactivity was ex
amined toward several commonly used spin traps. Reaction rates and pro
duct distributions were determined. The isomeric biradicals were found
to possess remarkably different chemical properties. Most importantly
, the 2,6-dimethylenepyridinium biradical is highly reactive toward al
l the reagents studied, while the 3,5-dimethylenepyridinium biradical
reacts slowly or not at all. The reaction of the 2,6-dimethylenepyridi
nium biradical with tert-butyl isocyanide occurs via HCN abstraction a
nd addition, the same pathways observed for isomeric closed-shell pyri
dylmethyl cations. In contrast, the 3,5-dimethylenepyridinium biradica
l reacts exclusively by slow addition. The same reaction was observed
for the analogous 3-methylenepyridinium monoradical ion. The 3,5-dimet
hylenepyridinium biradical and the 3-methylenepyridinium monoradical a
lso display similar reactivity toward the other reagents studied, whil
e this is not the case for the 2,6-dimethylenepyridinium biradical and
the pyridylmethyl cations. Some of the differences observed in the re
activity of the isomeric biradicals are likely explained by their diff
erent ground-state multiplicities. Earlier ab initio molecular orbital
calculations predict a triplet ground state for the 3,5-dimethylenepy
ridinium biradical (by about 6 kcal/mol) and a closed-shell singlet gr
ound state for the 2,6-dimethylenepyridinium biradical (by about 2 kca
l/mol). The different location of the protonated nitrogen relative to
the methylene groups probably has a minor influence over the types of
reaction products obtained since this is the case for the analogous mo
noradicals.